Counting on too much upside is a recipe for disaster on a team!

Photo by Sol Tucker for TalkNats

Counting on too much upside is a recipe for a disaster on a team! As Washington Nationals‘ general manager Mike Rizzo added veterans to the roster recently, they are all coming off of down years. The odds are, that not all of them will have bounceback seasons. Jeimer Candelario, Dominic Smith, and Corey Dickerson were all added by the Nats on MLB deals, and last year they hit .217, .194, and .267 respectively.

Staying optimistic on those three aforementioned players is what you do in the offseason, but when disaster strikes like it did last year with 42 year old Nelson Cruz, fans immediately turn to what [the bleep] was the G.M. thinking when he signed a .226 batter to a $15 million contract?  By the way, Cruz signed this year for a reported $1 million with the Padres.

Rizzo has long maintained that veteran players on down years return to their career norms like water that finds its level. Rizzo also likes to quote the trusty back of the baseball card for players to return to career averages. Well, rivers go through long droughts and baseball cards fade if left out in the sun for too long.

“The guys that we have in the lineup have done it before, big back-of-the-baseball-card kind of things,” Rizzo said. “These guys have all done it [before], and we expect them to play up to their potential and not do more than we expect them to do but play up to their potential. If they do that, we’re gonna score enough runs to supplement our good pitching, our good bullpen — and win a lot of games.”

Now if Candelario and Smith return to their career .730-ish OPS numbers or better, they will both help this Nats’ team win games. If they return to their OPS seasons of .872 and .993 respectively that both produced in 2020, they might both be All-Stars. But in addition to the new signings, the Nats are hoping for Victor Robles and CJ Abrams to hit to their potential.

And it is not just the hitters that the Nats need to return to their best form, the team needs Patrick Corbin to find that 2019 form, and Josiah Gray to pitch to what they saw when he first came to the Nats.

Yes, there is going to be a lot of wishing and hoping and -ifs- with this current roster. Going by today’s projections on FanGraphs, they are expecting Keibert Ruiz and Abrams to tie for the team lead with a +2.6 WAR. That is not a big stretch for Ruiz who was a +1.7 WAR in 112 games last year, but Abrams in his first year was a -0.2 WAR in his 44 games for Washington. FanGraphs is projecting regression for Meneses this season, however for most of the players they see positive contributions.

Here is what a Nats lineup could look like today against right-handed pitching:

1. Lane Thomas RF (R)
2. Keibert Ruiz C (S)
3. Jeimer Candelario 3B (S)
4. Dominic Smith 1B (L)
5. Joey Meneses DH (R)
6. Corey Dickerson LF (L)
7. CJ Abrams SS (L)
8. Luis García 2B (L)
9. Victor Robles CF (R)

Here are some roster possibilities as players are less than a month away from meeting in West Palm Beach for Spring Training:

Starting pitchers (5): Cade CavalliPatrick CorbinMacKenzie GoreJosiah GrayTrevor Williams
Relief pitchers (8): Sean Doolittle (NRI), Carl Edwards Jr.Kyle FinneganHunter HarveyErasmo RamirezMason ThompsonThad Ward, Paolo Espino
Catchers (2): Keibert RuizRiley Adams
Infielders/DH (7): CJ Abrams,  Jeimer CandelarioLuis GarcíaDominic SmithIldemaro Vargas, Joey MenesesMatt Adams (NRI) -or-  Michael Chavis (NRI) -or- Jake Alu -or- Carter Kieboom
Outfielders (4): Corey DickersonVictor RoblesLane ThomasAlex Call, -or- Stone Garrett

There are a lot of contenders there for the Comeback Player of the Year award. Who will make the team as the 26th player and why? Who will be this year’s biggest positive surprise?

The post Counting on too much upside is a recipe for disaster on a team! appeared first on


Counting on too much upside is a recipe for disaster on a team!